Federal judge says Josh Duggar wanted court to believe 'magic bullet theory,' denies his ...
nwaonline.com
Josh Duggar's failed "magic bullet theory" defense reveals how courts dissect implausible single-cause explanations — and why judges aren't buying it.
Magic Bullet TheoryOccam's RazorBurden of ProofMotivated Reasoning
Theory Briefing
- A federal judge denied Josh Duggar's motion to vacate his child porn sentence, calling his defense a 'magic bullet theory.'
- Duggar's legal team argued a single alternative explanation could account for all evidence, a classically flawed defense strategy.
- The ruling shows how 'magic bullet' reasoning — demanding one tidy cause for complex evidence — routinely fails judicial scrutiny.