No I will not specify wich theories I think go where : r/fivenightsatfreddys - Reddit
reddit.com
FNAF fans are wrestling with a classic narrative theory dilemma: can a story be "true" lore-wise but still fail as storytelling — and does it even matter?
Death of the AuthorNarrative TheoryCanon vs. FanonIntentional Fallacy
Theory Briefing
- Reddit users argue many accepted FNAF theories are canon but narratively unsatisfying, questioning Scott Cawthon's storytelling craft.
- The debate hinges on whether internal consistency makes a theory 'good' even if it produces a poor story experience.
- Fans split on separating authorial intent from narrative quality — a live case study in death-of-the-author thinking.