Paraguay upsets Germany in penalty kicks for biggest World Cup shock so far - NBC News
nbcnews.com
Paraguay's goalkeeper made two shootout saves to knock out Germany — and now the 2026 World Cup's biggest upset is rewriting expectations about who belongs at the top.
Upset TheoryGame TheoryRegression to the MeanCompetitive Balance

Theory Briefing
- Paraguay beat Germany 4-3 on penalties, a result that defies the massive gap in FIFA rankings and tournament pedigree between the two sides.
- Two key goalkeeper saves in the shootout were the decisive factor, showing how a single player's moment can neutralize a superior squad.
- Penalty shootouts are near-coin-flip scenarios statistically, meaning even heavy favorites carry real elimination risk every knockout round.
- The upset raises questions about whether traditional football powers retain a structural edge when matches go to penalties.