[Spoiler extended]What are theories you don't agree with and why? : r/asoiaf - Reddit
reddit.com
A Game of Thrones fan community stress-tests its own lore theories — revealing how confirmation bias and motivated reasoning shape even fictional world-building debates.
Confirmation BiasMotivated ReasoningFalsifiabilityGroupthink
Theory Briefing
- Reddit's ASOIAF community debates which popular fan theories lack textual evidence, exposing how groupthink inflates weak ideas.
- Users apply falsifiability to fictional lore, rejecting theories that rely on selective reading or wishful thinking about beloved characters.
- The thread shows how motivated reasoning leads fans to defend theories that feel satisfying rather than those best supported by the text.