theorypedia
← Back to feed

Why the 'extreme male brain' theory of autism has been disowned | The Spectator

spectator.com

Simon Baron-Cohen built his career on the "extreme male brain" theory of autism — and now he's the one walking away from it.

Extreme Male Brain TheoryCognitive Empathising-Systemising TheoryKuhnian Paradigm ShiftConfirmation Bias
Why the 'extreme male brain' theory of autism has been disowned | The Spectator

Theory Briefing

  • Sir Simon Baron-Cohen, who originally championed the extreme male brain theory, is himself distancing from it — a rare case of a theorist disowning his own landmark idea.
  • The theory held that autism represents an extreme version of male-typical cognitive traits like systemising over empathising, shaping decades of research and diagnosis.
  • Growing evidence around autistic women and gender-diverse individuals challenged the model's core assumption that autism maps neatly onto biological sex differences.
  • Baron-Cohen's reversal raises questions about how long influential but flawed frameworks can steer clinical practice before the field corrects course.